ALZ

Wow. Really unexpected and nicely done.

I went through it once not interacting with anything, and the end worked like a clue... that I interpreted completely wrong.
The whole style of the game (visually and in terms of gameplay) really takes its full meaning after the "reveal".

Congrats to dyl, this is a great first endeavour.

... It is bad that the review, which can be summed up as "This is a very, very depressing game." made me want to play it more that another style?

Having played it, I can say the review was exactly correct: the story was sad, but the execution was wonderful. Without giving too much away, I can say that the artist perfectly hit the nail on the head concerning the subject matter. The story does not come together until toward the end, but it rapidly clicks together all the pieces like a magnetic jigsaw puzzle. One of the better art game I've played in a while!

Oh.
Oh, wow. That's... that's just beautiful. Ouch.

The music fits the game and it's theme really well.

Ah, so heart-wrenchingly beautiful. It's been awhile since we've gotten one of these ones.

And it's set to Broove as well. I will always remember Heartbeats.

This is a sensitive and thoughtful presentation.

The makers of this game clearly know their subject very well, so my heart goes out to them, as this topic if very hard to get your head around.

It's not working for me. I'm using Firefox, and the game seemed to load fine but now it's just playing music from a black screen.

I'm not actually sure I played the WHOLE game but reached replay.
Almost crashing Flash/Shockwave JUST before you 100% load kinda sucks too.

Some of these games doing this is getting old, especially after literally JUST updating both flash AND shockwave.

Pathetic: It seems to be becoming a trend, to create little "interactive art" games with a minimum of ideas: "What is this life all about?" etc. I'm not really a big fan of comparing, but if something completely lacks innovation and a idea of its own (and this "game" does in my opinion)althiough it could only work, if it really was innovative: I would give it zero stars, as I gave games like Botanicula (representing the other extreme) 5.

Michael, I have to srongly disagree with your points here.
This game clearly aimed at tackling only one idea, and it wasn't anything as broad and vage as "What is this life all about?". The single idea it did choose to deal with was actually presented in at least one innovative way: the relation between art style and subject. There are many other creative points to it, but that one easily and demonstrably stands out.

The comparison with Botanicula is really inadequate, as those games aim at very different goals. Botanicula is a beautiful puzzle game. ALZ is a lot more like a picture, a text, or a song about its theme. Not really comparable.

Why make it a game, then? One reason is because in this medium a very big part of the temporality is in control of the player. Things happen at a pace that is not imposed by the artist. Not everything is discovered/seen/read at the same time, in the same order, or even at all for everyone, and that alone already makes for a more engaging (and engaged) experience.
The fact that it's presented as a game with very little information about it also contributes to its effectiveness: the theme is still an unexpected one for the medium (yet another point for innovation). Moreover, the way that theme is brought about only at the very end, resignifying all that preceded it, is a lesson in formal consistency many writers could use.

This particular form, with its particular interactiveness and consequent impact, is typical of videogames. Quite hard to achieve otherwise.

So yeah, if *this* is becoming a trend (which I don't think it is), I'm all for it.

No, I agree with Michael. Whenever I hit games in this trend, I come expecting a game. What I end up with is not a game but a movie that requires me to press space or the right arrow key to get through it, and I feel gypped out of an actual gaming experience. This should have just been posted as a movie to save time on programming, and to get more 'views.' Also to be less along the lines of false advertising.

The careful construction and emotional resonance of ALZ were somewhat undermined by the Evony ad that played alongside it, continuously displaying a massive bosom at the same level as the player character's head.

For the experience, I like it, it is beautiful. But I also would have to agree it is not even actually interactive art. There is not even a single choice to make or illusion of choices. I played a number of game titles that are focusing on telling reality stories, some have actual choices yet most often it means the message will be obscured by gameplay, some have illusion of choices which most likely the ideal situation, some have no choices at all these ones leave me in wondering if I should give a 5 star or 1 star.

In the end? Game is medium just like a paint is medium. Some people would argue that painting on canvas is more art or beautiful than painting on walls, some don't. So, is this a game? Nope. Is it an interesting story about life? Yes.

Beautiful

My father passed away from Alzheimer's last Christmas, and this made me cry. So, I believe it succeeded at something.